1
16303108.3 8/11/2023
APPENDIX B
An Explanation of Distinctions Between the Processes Under New York State Penal Law and the
Brooklyn Law School Sexual Misconduct Policy
Brooklyn Law School Sexual Misconduct Policy
Public safety; deterrence; and
punishment.
Education; safety; prevention, redress, supportive
campus environment.
New York State Penal Code; New
York State Rules of Criminal
Procedure (or another state’s rules if
the crime took place there), Federal
Criminal Law, and Rules of Evidence.
Title IX; The Clery Act as amended by the Violence
Against Women Act; NYS Education Law Sections
129-A and 129-B and BLS policies, including the
Sexual Misconduct and Anti-Harassment and
Discrimination Policies which trigger an investigation.
whether there must
be action once a
report is made.
Crimes involving sexual misconduct
may be reported to campus police (if
the campus has police officers), the
local police agency, or to the New
York State Police. Certain crimes may
also be reported to federal law
enforcement agents. Once a report is
made, the decision whether to
investigate is made by the police/law
enforcement agency, often in
consultation with a District Attorney
or other prosecuting agency. An
investigation may be conducted
without the consent or participation of
a reporting individual. The ultimate
decision of whether to initiate a
criminal prosecution is initially made
by a prosecutor. In cases involving
felony charges, the final charging
decision is made by a Grand Jury.
Victims may disclose sexual misconduct to
“responsible employees” which will trigger an
investigation. Every effort will be made to ensure
privacy to the extent consistent with the institution’s
obligation to provide a safe educational environment.
Disclosures made to confidential resources, such as
clergy or a mental health professional, will not trigger
an investigation. When a report is made to the Title IX
Coordinator, the Coordinator will determine whether
an investigation is necessary by weighing a request for
confidentiality by the reporting individual against the
continuing safety of that person and the safety and best
interests of the campus community.
Police or other law enforcement
officials.
The Title IX Coordinator.
See Governing Law. Procedures
established by police departments,
prosecutors’ offices, etc.
The procedures are established by the Brooklyn Law
School Sexual Misconduct Policy.
Evidence
Crimes must be proven “Beyond a
Reasonable Doubt”
A violation of disciplinary rules must be found by a
“Preponderance of the Evidence” (more likely than
Law enforcement agencies offer some
confidential assistance, but a criminal
charge and trial must be public.
Confidential resources are available off-campus, such
as clergy and mental health professionals, but a
disciplinary proceeding requires that relevant
information be shared with those involved.
Criminal trials must be public.
Disciplinary proceedings are kept as private as
possible, but information must be shared with certain
individuals within the Law School, the parties, and
parties?
The prosecution and defendant. The
victim/survivor is not a party, but
often the critical witness for the
The institution and the respondent can be the parties.
Otherwise, the reporting individual and
accused/respondent are the parties.